The following are the all-time honors for the Concordia University Football program from the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA), Mid-States Football Association (MSFA), College Sport Communicators (CSC), and the Associated Press (AP). The honors are of events played through the 2022 season.
| NAIA |
| MSFA |
| NCCAA |
| CSC |
| AP |
NAIA
NAIA/AFCA 1ST TEAM ALL-AMERICAN
Conner, Joe – 2018 (Running Back)
DeGayner, Seeger - 2022 (All-Purpose), 2023 (All-Purpose)
Hinojosa, Alex - 2020 (Defensive End)
Johnson, Takari – 2014 (Linebacker)
Rauch, Casey - 2021 (Punter)
NAIA/AFCA 2ND TEAM ALL-AMERICAN
Foerster, Andrew - 2021 (Defensive Line)
Rauch, Casey - 2023 (Linebacker)
NAIA/AFCA HONORABLE MENTION
Corlew, Donovan – 2018 (Offensive Line), 2019 (Offensive Line)
Fish, Ryan - 2020 (Defensive Back)
CLIFF HARRIS AWARD NOMINEE
Johnson, Takari – 2014 *Received most votes out of any NAIA player
Holshoe, Nick – 2015
NAIA SCHOLAR-ATHLETE (3.5 G.P.A. or Above & at least a Sophomore Academically)
Breen, Daniel - 2018
Bugg, Eric - 2018
Chickeral, Mike – 2016
Christensen, Collin - 2015, 2016
Cox, Gabe – 2013, 2014
Cox, Hunter – 2015, 2016
DeVries, Harmon - 2022, 2023
Douglass, Elijah - 2023
Dowling, Gabe - 2022, 2023
Dowling, Will - 2021, 2022, 2023
Duff, Joe - 2018
Duff, Robert – 2014
Engel, Parker - 2023
Erni, Shayne - 2021
Flower, Heath - 2021, 2022, 2023
Foerster, Andrew - 2020
Foster, Jordan - 2013
Greenwood, Tom – 2012
Jones, Darricle – 2016, 2017
Kado, Maurice - 2023
Kermode, Hayden - 2022
Koehler, Lucas – 2015, 2016
Koehler, Tim – 2017, 2018
Kohmescher, Colby - 2021, 2022, 2023
Koski, Jay - 2017, 2018
Maynard, Chase - 2023
Maynard, Hunter - 2020
McCulley, Dawson - 2022
Miller, Richard - 2023
Mlynarek, Jake - 2021, 2022
Morrison, Peter - 2020
Nahrwold-Settle, Logan - 2022, 2023
Needham, Tristen - 2022, 2023
O’Brien, Ross - 2018
Painter, Nick - 2021, 2022
Payne, Amaan - 2018
Peterson, Ty – 2015, 2016
Pranger, Tristan - 2023
Prioleau, Zaire - 2022
Rauch, Casey - 2021, 2022, 2023
Robinson, Ryan - 2022, 2023
Schick, Sam - 2016, 2017
Scribner, Conner - 2021
Shafer, Sam - 2022
Smith, Nathan – 2012
Soderberg, Kenneth - 2022
Stefanski, Corbin - 2020, 2021
VanderVliet, Matthew – 2012, 2013
Vizina, Jaden - 2023
Weimer, Andrew - 2021, 2022, 2023
Zalewski, Aaron – 2013
NAIA PLAYER OF THE WEEK
Edney, Nick - 2018
Gomez, Luis - 2020
Rauch, Casey - 2020
MSFA
MSFA MIDEAST OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR
Conner, Joe - 2018
MSFA MIDEAST DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR
Hinojosa, Alex - 2020
Johnson, Takari - 2013, 2014
MSFA MIDEAST 1ST TEAM
Cagle, David - 2023
Conner, Joe - 2016, 2017, 2018
Corlew, Donovan - 2018, 2019
Cyr, Norman - 2016
Dailey, Roderick - 2018, 2019
DeGayner, Seeger - 2022, 2023 x2
Dowling, Will - 2023
Fish, Ryan - 2020
Gomez, Luis - 2020
Hill, Ra-Heem - 2017
Hinojosa, Alex - 2019, 2020
Holshoe, Nick - 2015
Hudson, Bryant - 2017
Johnson, Takari - 2013, 2014
Jones, Darricle - 2017
Kukulies, Josh - 2017
Mason, Herman - 2017
Maynard, Hunter - 2021
McHenry Jr., Gerald - 2021
Muxlow, Caleb - 2020
O’Hara, Andrew - 2017, 2018
Polhman, Kaleb - 2017
Rauch, Casey - 2021, 2022, 2023 x2
Roehr, Nathan - 2021
Sinclair, Omar - 2018, 2019 x2
Stewart, Brandon - 2022
Vallott, Steven - 2018
Wilson, Luke - 2020, 2021
MSFA MIDEAST 2ND TEAM
Alvarez, Jay - 2017
Bennett, Brayden - 2016
Brown, Keviontae - 2020
Corlew, Donovan - 2017
DeGayner, Seeger - 2022
Desalle, Donte - 2017, 2018
Dowling, Gabe - 2021, 2022
Dowling, Will - 2021, 2022
Edney, Nick - 2017, 2018
Foerster, Andrew - 2020, 2021
Gifford, Nathan - 2017
Graham, Parker - 2020, 2021
Holshoe, Nick - 2016
Ibe, Kelechukwu - 2011
Johnson, Alonzo - 2022
Karry, Liam - 2023
Koehler, Tim - 2017, 2018
Kohmescher, Colby - 2023
Koski, Jay - 2017, 2018
Mason, Herman - 2016
Mast, Wyatt - 2019
O’Hara, Andrew - 2015
Peterson, Ty - 2016
Pohlman, Kaleb - 2016
Rauch, Casey - 2020, 2021, 2022
Rubin, Keith - 2017
Suida, Seth - 2017
Thompson, Reggie - 2019
Turner, Corey - 2014, 2015
Vallot, Steven - 2019
Vushaj, Edison - 2012
Williams, James - 2020
MSFA MIDEAST HONORABLE MENTION
Alex AyoOla, Prince - 2019
Coltson, Clay - 2019
Cox, Hunter - 2014, 2015
Cyr, Norman - 2014, 2015
Dalou, Tarek - 2017, 2018
Degayner, Seeger - 2021
Fish, Ryan - 2018
Freeman, Treyon - 2022
Greenwood, Tom - 2011, 2012
Holshoe, Nick - 2013
Iltis, Tim - 2017
Johnson, Takari - 2012
Jones, Darricle - 2016
Karry, Liam - 2023
Knott, Tom - 2013
Long, Connor - 2020
Matthews, Kelly - 2023
Maynard, Hunter - 2020
Merhi, Ed - 2018
O’Gara, Cooper - 2019
O’Hara, Andrew - 2016
Painter, Nick - 2022
Payne, Amaan - 2017
Peterson, Ty - 2014
Pohlman, Kaleb 2015
Rahn, Aaron - 2021
Roehr, Nathan - 2022
Rubin, Keith - 2016
Scarber, Dimarco - 2012
Smith, Cortez - 2012
Stefanski, Corbin - 2021
Turner, Corey - 2013
Vaughn, Collin - 2020
Watson, LeRoy - 2023
Whitmore, Gabe - 2023
Woods, Kelvin - 2012
WHAC A.O. DUER AWARD
Morrison, Peter - 2018, 2019
MSFA ALL-ACADEMIC
Allen, Broderick - 2021
Beerer, Brendan - 2019
Belinsky, Zachary - 2020, 2021
Bennett, Brayden - 2015, 2016
Blosser, Mike - 2015
Brooks, Bailey - 2023
Brooks, Gavin - 2021, 2022, 2023
Breen, Daniel - 2017, 2018, 2019
Bugg, Eric - 2017, 2018
Carpenter, James - 2021, 2022, 2023
Chickeral, Mike - 2015, 2016
Christensen, Collin - 2015, 2016
Cox, Gabe - 2013, 2014
Cox, Hunter - 2015
Crenshaw, Hunter - 2021
Demaagd, Logan - 2015
DeSantis, Booby - 2018, 2019
DeVries, Harmon - 2022, 2023
Douglass, Elijah - 2021, 2022, 2023
Dowling, Gabe - 2021, 2022, 2023
Dowling, Will - 2021, 2022, 2023
Duff, Joe - 2017, 2018
Duff, Robert - 2013, 2014
Emmendorfer, Collin - 2019
Engel, Parker - 2023
Erni, Shayne - 2020
Fish, Ryan - 2019, 2020
Flower, Heath - 2021, 2022, 2023
Foerster, Andrew - 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021
Foster, Jordan - 2013, 2014
Gott, Jett - 2023
Greenwood, Tom - 2012
Gullen, Mason - 2023
Gemm, Dairen - 2023
Hay, Logan - 2022, 2023
Hobbs, Dakota - 2020
Jones, Darricle - 2016, 2017
Kado, Maurice - 2022, 2023
Karry, Laim - 2023
Kelley, Shawn - 2016, 2017
Kermode, Hayden - 2022
Koehler, Lucas - 2015, 2016
Koehler, Tim - 2016, 2017, 2018
Kohmescher, Colby - 2021, 2022, 2023
Koski, Jay - 2017, 2018
Krogen, Matt - 2014, 2015
Kukulies, Joshua - 2016, 2017
Lyons, Matthew - 2023
Matthews, Kelly - 2023
Maynard, Chase - 2023
Maynard, Hunter - 2019, 2020, 2021
McCulley, Dawson - 2022
Miller, Richard - 2021, 2022, 2023
Mlynarek, Jake - 2020, 2021, 2022
Morrison, Peter - 2018, 2019, 2020
Nahrwold-Settle, Logan - 2022, 2023
Needham, Tristan - 2022, 2023
O’Brien, Ross - 2016, 2017, 2018
O’Gara, Cooper - 2017, 2019
Osborne, Matt - 2019
Painter, Nick - 2020, 2021, 2022
Payne, Amaan - 2017, 2018, 2019
Peterson, Ty - 2015, 2016
Pittenger, Evan - 2022, 2023
Pohlman, Kaleb - 2016, 2017
Pranger, Tristan - 2023
Prioleau, Zaire - 2022, 2023
Rader, Brady - 2020, 2021
Rauch, Casey - 2021, 2022, 2023
Robinson, Ryan - 2022, 2023
Rubin, Keith - 2017, 2018
Rufo, Noah - 2019
Schick, Josh - 2012
Schick, Sam - 2016, 2017
Scribner, Connor - 2020, 2021
Shaban, Austin - 2020, 2021
Shafer, Sam - 2021, 2022
Shutt, John Mark - 2020, 2021
Smith, Hunter - 2020
Smith, Nathan - 2012, 2013
Smith, Nolan - 2020
Soderberg, Kenneth - 2022
Steel, Tyler - 2014
Stefanski, Corbin - 2019, 2020, 2021
Stewart, Brandon - 2022
VanDalsen, Jaden - 2022
Van Dyke, Andrew - 2023
VanderVliet, Matthew - 2012, 2013
Vizina, Jaden - 2021, 2022, 2023
Wade, Andrew - 2020
Wagner, Ty - 2023
Wallis, Cody - 2022
West, Thomas - 2016
Wiemer, Andrew - 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023
Willburn, Terrence - 2014
Williams, James - 2019
Wood, Max - 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021
Yancey, ToRohn - 2021
Zalewski, Aaron - 2012, 2013
MSFA MIDEAST OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE WEEK
Brooks, Gavin - 2021 x2, 2023 x2
Brown, Keviontae 2020
Conner, Joe - 2017, 2018 x3
Degayner, Seeger - 2022, 2023
Desalle, Donte - 2017
Sinclair, Omar - 2019 x2
Stewart, Brandon - 2022
MSFA MIDEAST DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE WEEK
Edney, Nick - 2017, 2018
Fish, Ryan - 2019, 2020
Foerster, Andrew - 2020, 2021
Hill, Ra-Heem - 2017
Hinojosa, Alex - 2019, 2020
Holshoe, Nick - 2015 2x
Johnson, Takari – 2013, 2014 x2
Karry, Liam - 2023
Kohmescher, Colby - 2022
Koski, Jay - 2017
Maynard, Chase - 2023 x2
Maynard, Hunter - 2021 x3 - 3 Consecutive Weeks
O’Hara, Andrew - 2017 x2, 2018
Rahn, Aaron - 2021
Rauch, Casey - 2023 x2
Whitmore, Gabe - 2020, 2021
MSFA MIDEAST SPECIAL TEAMS PLAYER OF THE WEEK
Degayner, Seeger - 2020, 2022 2x
Gomez, Luis - 2020 x2, 2021
Greenwood, Tom – 2012 x2
Kukulies, Joshua - 2017
Rauch, Casey - 2020 x2, 2022, 2023
Robinson, Dejai - 2023
Thomas, Caiden - 2023
NCCAA
NCCAA PLAYER OF THE YEAR
Cagle, David - 2023
Conner, Joe - 2018
Fish, Ryan - 2020
NCCAA ALL-AMERICA 1ST TEAM
Cagle, David - 2023
Conner, Joe - 2017, 2018
Corlew, Donovan - 2018, 2019
Dailey, Roderick - 2018, 2019
Dalou, Tarek - 2018
DeGayner, Seeger - 2022
Dowling, Will - 2023
Fish, Ryan - 2018, 2019, 2020
Foerster, Andrew - 2020
Gomez, Luis - 2020
Hinojosa, Alex - 2019, 2020
Jones, Darricle - 2017
Koehler, Tim 2018
Koski, Jay - 2018
Muxlow, Caleb - 2020
O’Hara, Andrew - 2017, 2018
Rauch, Casey - 2022, 2023
Thompson, Reggie - 2019
Vallot, Steven - 2018
Weimer, Andrew - 2023
Williams, James - 2020
Wilson, Luke - 2020
NCCAA ALL-AMERICA 2ND TEAM
Brice, Collin - 2023
Brown, Keviontae - 2020
Degayner, Seeger - 2020, 2023
Dowling, Will - 2022
Dowling, Gabe - 2022
Dupree, Marvitus - 2022
Graham, Parker - 2020
Herman, Mason - 2017
Hill, Ra-Heem - 2017
Johnson, Alonzo - 2022
Koski, Jay - 2017
Long, Connor - 2020
Mason, Herman - 2017
Mast, Wyatt - 2019
Maynard, Hunter - 2020
O’Hara, Andrew - 2017
Pohlman, Kaleb - 2017
Rahn, Aaron - 2020
Rauch, Casey - 2020, 2023
Sinclair, Omar - 2018, 2019
Vallot, Steven - 2019
NCCAA ALL-AMERICA HONORABLE MENTION
Koehler, Tim - 2017
Kukulies, Joshua - 2017
Suida, Seth - 2017
NCCAA SCHOLAR-ATHLETE
Belinsky, Zach - 2021
Brooks, Gavin - 2023
Carpenter, James - 2022, 2023
DeVries, Harmon - 2023
Douglass, Elijah - 2023
Dowling, Gabe - 2023
Dowling, Will - 2022, 2023
Erni, Shayne - 2021
Flower, Heath - 2022, 2023
Foerster, Andrew - 2021
Kado, Maurice - 2023
Kohmescher, Colby - 2022, 2023
Maynard, Hunter - 2021
Mlynarek, Jake - 2021, 2022
Nahrwold-Settle, Logan - 2023
Needham, Tristen - 2023
Painter, Nicholas - 2021, 2022
Pittenger, Evan - 2023
Prioleau, Zaire - 2023
Rauch, Casey - 2022, 2023
Robinson, Ryan - 2023
Scribner, Connor - 2021
Shutt, John - 2021
Stefanski, Corbin - 2021
Vizina, Jaden - 2022, 2023
Weimer, Andrew - 2021, 2022, 2023
Wood, Max - 2021
NCCAA PLAYER OF THE WEEK
Brooks, Gavin - 2021, 2023
Cagle, David - 2022, 2023
Coltson, Clay - 2019
Conner, Joe - 2018 x2
Dailey, Roderick - 2018
DeGayner, Seeger - 2022, 2023 x2
Desalle, Donte - 2017
Edney, Nick - 2018
Fish, Ryan - 2018, 2019, 2020
Hinojosa, Alex - 2019
Karry, Liam - 2023
Koehler, Tim - 2018
Kohmescher, Colby - 2023
Koski, Jay - 2017 x2, 2018
Maynard, Chase - 2023
Maynard, Hunter - 2021 x3 Won 3 Consecutive Weeks
O’Hara, Andrew - 2017, 2018 x2
Pohlman, Kaleb - 2017
Rahn, Aaron - 2020, 2021 x2
Rauch, Casey - 2021, 2023 x2
Sinclair, Omar - 2019
Suida, Seth - 2017 x2
Thompson, Reggie - 2018
Wiemer, Andrew - 2022
CSC
CSC FIRST TEAM ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICA (*Award based on performance athletically & academically - CUAA started recognizing in 2016 - previously CoSIDA)
Cox, Hunter - 2016
Dowling, Will - 2023
Foerster, Andrew - 2021
Koehler, Tim - 2018
Koski, Jay - 2017
Maynard, Hunter - 2021
Rauch, Casey - 2022
CSC ACADEMIC ALL-DISTRICT (*Award based on performance athletically & academically - CUAA started recognizing in 2016 - previously CoSIDA)
Cox, Hunter – 2016
DeVries, Harmon - 2022, 2023
Dowling, Gabe - 2021, 2022
Dowling, Will - 2021, 2022, 2023
Foerster, Andrew - 2019, 2020, 2021
Jones, Darricle – 2016, 2017
Kelley, Shawn – 2017
Koehler, Lucas – 2016
Koehler, Tim – 2016, 2017, 2018
Kohmescher, Colby - 2022, 2023
Koski, Jay – 2016, 2017, 2018
Maynard, Chase - 2023
Maynard, Hunter - 2020, 2021
Narhwold-Settle, Logan - 2022
O’Gara, Cooper - 2019
Painter, Nick - 2020, 2021, 2022
Payne, Amaan – 2018, 2019
Peterson, Ty – 2016
Pohlman, Kaleb – 2017
Rauch, Casey - 2021, 2022, 2023
Stefanski, Corbin - 2021
Wiemer, Andrew - 2022, 2023
CUAA started recognizing in 2016 - previously CoSIDA
College Sports Communicators is a 3,200+ member national association for strategic, creative, and digital communicators across intercollegiate athletics in the United States and Canada. The organization was previously known as College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA) and was changed to its new name in August of 2022.
Nominees for the All-District team must have participated in at least 50% of the team's matches throughout the season while maintaining a cumulative GPA of 3.50. The student-athlete must also complete one full calendar year at the institution and reach sophomore athletic eligibility in order to qualify for the honor.
AP
AP FIRST TEAM
Casey Rauch - 2021 - Punter
AP SECOND TEAM
DeGayner, Seeger - 2022 - Return Specialist
Wilson, Luke - 2021 - Tight End