The following are the all-time honors for the Concordia University Men's Cross Country program from the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA), Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference (WHAC), and the National Christian College Athletic Association (NCCAA). The honors are of events played through the 2023 season.
| NAIA |
| WHAC |
| NCCAA |
NAIA
NAIA ALL-AMERICAN SCHOLAR-ATHLETE (Began in 2008 - 3.5 G.P.A. or Above & at least a Junior Academically)
Belt, Andrew - 2012
Bentz, Luke - 2022, 2023
Bjellquist-Ledger, Ryan - 2014, 2015
Burmeister, Ryan - 2010
Cantrell, Will - 2010
Eising, Theodore - 2023
Fisch, Adam - 2023
Gardner, Andrew - 2014, 2015
Haiderer, Michael - 2008
Kitchin, Alex - 2014
Sanchez, Avery - 2023
Schmit, Stever - 2008-09
Starkey, Noah - 2022, 2023
Stiver, Jared - 2023
WHAC
WHAC ALL-ACADEMIC TEAM (3.25 G.P.A. or Above & at least a Junior Academically)
Bailey, Ryan - 2018
Belt, Andrew - 2012
Bentz, Luke - 2023
Binkowski, Brandon - 2016
Bjellquist-Ledger, Ryan - 2013, 2014, 2015
Bowdish, Grant - 2018
Brinton, Joseph - 2016
Burmeister, Ryan - 2009, 2010
Cantrell, Will - 2011
Eising, Theodore - 2022, 2023
Fisch, Adam - 2023
Gardner, Andrew - 2014, 2015
Gaynier, David - 2016
Grimm, Timothy - 2014
Haiderer, Michael - 2008
Heierman, Nate - 2016
Kitchin, Alex - 2013, 2014
Sanchez, Avery - 2022, 2023
Schmit, Stever – 2008
Starkey, Noah - 2022, 2023
Stiver, Jared - 2023
WHAC RUNNER OF THE WEEK
Bauer, Micah - 2023 (2x)
Cantrell, Will - 2010
Kitchen, Alex - 2014
WHAC CHAMPIONS OF CHARACTER TEAM
Belt, Andrew - 2010, 2011
Bjellquist-Ledger, Ryan - 2015
Burmeister, Ryan - 2009
Case, Tyler - 2008
DiMaggio, Adam - 2019, 2020
Eising, Theodore - 2021
Finley, Noah - 2022
Gomori, Jack - 2018
Gonzalez-Feliciano, Miguel - 2014
Heierman, Nate - 2016
Kitchin, Alex - 2013
Stiver, Jared - 2023
NCCAA
NCCAA ALL-AMERICAN
Smetcka, Mike - 2000
NCCAA SCHOLAR-ATHLETE
Bentz, Luke - 2023
Bowdish, Grant - 2018
Sanchez, Avery - 2023
Starkey, Noah - 2022, 2023
