The following are honors for the Concordia University Softball program from the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA), Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference (WHAC), National Christian College Athletic Association (NCCAA), and the College Sport Communicators (CSC). The honors are of events played through the 2024 season.
| NAIA |
| WHAC |
| NCCAA |
| CSC |
| NFCA |
NAIA
NAIA FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS
Santiago, Robin - 2002
NAIA SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS
McAlinden, Shannon - 2023, 2024
NAIA HONORABLE MENTIONS
Landerschier, Lisa - 1994
Lewis, Payton - 2023
NAIA ALL-REGION
Cicero, Erin - 1998
Holmes, Kathie - 1997
Horton, Kim - 2002
Kennedy, Kelly - 1997, 1998
Kennedy, Kristy - 1998
Knight, Carrie - 1999
Landerschier, Lisa - 1994
Santiago, Robin - 2002
Wilson, Amy - 1997, 1998
NAIA ALL-DISTRICT 1st Team
Landerschier, Lisa - 1992, 1993, 1994
NAIA ALL-DISTRICT ACADEMIC
Shore, Vickie - 1992, 1993, 1994
NAIA ALL-AMERICAN SCHOLAR-ATHLETE (3.5 G.P.A. or Above & at least a Junior Academically)
Anderson, Paige - 2023, 2024
Barjaktarovich, Jessica - 2015
Begley, Abbie - 2021, 2022
Block, Audra - 1997
Bollenbacher, Jeni - 2011, 2012
Brady, Summer - 2024
Campbell, Deandra - 2023
Capuzzi, Samantha - 2018
Churchill, Hunter - 2015
Cox, Brooklin - 2024
Drzewiecki, Carley - 2020
Elias, Kate - 2022
England, Jessica - 2017, 2018
Gehrke, Kara - 2018
Grueter, Maddy - 2023, 2024
Kane, Cassidy - 2022, 2023, 2024
Hill, Kali - 2018
Hinkle, Megan - 2020, 2021
Jabara, Alyssa - 2020
Laib, Megan - 2020
Landerschier, Lisa - 1994
Lee, Bella - 2024
Lewis, Payton - 2023, 2024
Martin, Megan - 2024
McAlinden, Shannon - 2022, 2023, 2024
Paryaski, Emma - 2020
Playford, Koryn - 2021, 2022, 2023
Porter, Vanessa - 2006
Preuss, Miranda - 2007
Reichel, Lauren - 2021
Richardson, Melanie - 2020
Russell, Terra - 2007
Shaddock, Victoria - 2015
Shaffer, Auna - 2007
Shawl, Natalie - 2021
Stephenson, Jada - 2022, 2023, 2024
Traveglia, Caitlin - 2023
Tyrrell, Sarah - 2023, 2024
Woods, Cierra - 2018
WHAC
WHAC CONFERENCE PLAYER OF THE YEAR
Holmes, Kathie - 1997
Kennedy, Kelly - 1998
Lewis, Payton - 2023
McAlinden, Shannon - 2024
Santiago, Robin - 2002
WHAC NEWCOMER OF THE YEAR
Tobias, Katie - 2023
WHAC ALL-DEFENSIVE TEAM
Brierley, Cheyenne - Catcher - 2016
Capuzzi, Samantha - Outfield - 2016
Kane, Cassidy - 3rd Base - 2024
Lewis, Payton - Shortstop - 2022, 2023, 2024
McAlinden, Shannon - Outfield - 2022, 2023, 2024
Reichel, Lauren - Pitcher - 2019
Tobias, Katie - Catcher - 2023
WHAC FIRST TEAM ALL-CONFERENCE
Anderson, Paige - 2023
Block, Audra - 1995, 1996, 1997
Brierley, Cheyenne - 2013, 2015, 2016
Burdis, Erin - 1997, 1999
Capuzzi, Samantha - 2016
Campbell, Dee - 2023
Ferrell, Kim - 1993
Finch, Christina - 2005
Finzel, Becki - 1995, 1996
Gallon, Katie - 2011
Grueter, Maddy - 2022
Head, Amanda - 2003
Holmes, Kathie - 1996, 1997
Horton, Kim - 2001, 2002
Kane, Cassidy - 2024
Kennedy, Kelly - 1997, 1998
Kennedy, Kristy - 1999, 2000
Knight, Carrie - 1999
Knight, Jenny - 2000, 2001, 2002
Landerschier, Lisa - 1993, 1994
Lewis, Payton - 2022, 2023, 2024
Loar, Kortney - 2013, 2014
Martin, Angela - 2013
McAlinden, Shannon - 2022, 2023, 2024
McNeely, Nichole - 2005
Muller, Grace - 2013
Playford, Koryn - 2021, 2023
Reichel, Lauren - 2021
Santiago, Robin - 2001, 2002
Shore, Vickie - 1993
Slinker, Dawn - 1995
Tobias, Katie - 2023
Trionfi, Amy - 2016
Underwood, Emilee - 2024
Wilson, Amy - 1995, 1997, 1998
WHAC SECOND TEAM ALL-CONFERENCE
Begley, Abbie - 2021, 2022
Brabaw, Laura - 2008
Brierley, Cheyenne - 2014
Bollenbacher, Jeni - 2009, 2011, 2012
Butcher, Kristina - 2013
Capuzzi, Samantha - 2015, 2017, 2018
Carrillo, Valerie - 2014
Cicero, Erin - 1998
Dewey, Georgia - 2009
Dirobio, Erin - 2011, 2012
Fuerstenau, Lauren - 2000
Head, Amanda - 2002, 2005
Gallan, Katie - 2009
Greficz, Karen - 2012
Herriman, Catherine - 2010
Kabobel, Brooke - 1997
Kennedy, Kristy - 1997
Knight, Jenny - 1999
Laib, Megan - 2018
Martin, Angela - 2015
McAlinden, Shannon - 2021
Muller, Grace - 2011, 2012
Pearson, Carly - 2021
Pyle, Lindsey - 2014
Richardson, Melanie - 2019
Rotondo, Corrina - 2014
Ryba, Lyndsey - 2019
Sabol, Hannah - 2010
Seeley, Courtney - 2010
Slinker, Dawn - 1996
Starnes, Laura - 2001
Stephenson, Jada - 2023, 2024
Stowe, Stacey - 2000, 2001
Tobias, Katie - 2024
Trionfi, Amy - 2015, 2017
Tyrrell, Sarah - 2023
Waters, Iesha - 2015
Wilson, Amy - 1996
WHAC ALL-CONFERENCE SCHOLAR-ATHLETE (3.25 G.P.A. or Above & at least Junior Academically)
Anderson, Paige - 2024
Barjaktarovich, Jessica - 2015, 2016
Begley, Abbie - 2022
Benson, Mary Kay - 2005
Block, Audra - 1996, 1997
Bollenbacher, Jeni - 2011, 2012
Brady, Summer - 2024
Brittain, Elyse - 2024
Bryan, Tiffani - 2019, 2020
Burdis, Erin - 1998
Capuzzi, Samantha - 2017, 2018
Churchill, Hunter - 2015, 2016
Cox, Brooklin - 2024
Dirobbio, Erin - 2011
Drzewiecki, Carley - 2019, 2020
Duchene, Hannah - 2024
Economou, Hannah - 2020
Elias, Kate - 2022
England, Jessica - 2017, 2018
Eubanks, Samantha - 2018
Foster, Jayla - 2024
Gehrke, Kara - 2018, 2019
Greficz, Karen - 2011, 2012
Grueter, Maddy - 2024
Hayworth, Erica - 2012
Herriman, Catherine - 2011, 2012
Hill, Kali - 2018, 2019
Hinkle, Megan - 2020, 2021
Jabara, Alyssa - 2019, 2020
Kane, Cassidy - 2022, 2023, 2024
Kennedy, Kristy - 1999
Kent, Karley - 2022
Kordick, Laura - 2009, 2010
Laib, Megan - 2019, 2020
Landerschier, Lisa - 1994
Lee, Bella - 2024
Lewis, Payton - 2024
Majeran, Grace - 2020
Malik, Stephanie - 2000
Martin, Megan - 2024
McAlinden, Shannon - 2023, 2024
Muller, Grace - 2012
Murat, Carly - 2018
Otter, Marisa - 2005
Paryaski, Emma - 2020, 2021
Pearson, Carly - 2020
Playford, Koryn - 2022, 2023
Porter, Vanessa - 2006
Preuss, Miranda - 2007
Reichel, Lauren - 2021
Rhodea, Lauryn - 2024
Richardson, Melanie - 2020
Russell, Terra - 2007, 2008
Seeley, Courtney - 2011
Shaddock, Victoria - 2015, 2016
Shaffer, Auna - 2007
Shawl, Natalie - 2021
Shingledecker, Lori - 1996
Shore, Vickie - 1993, 1994
Simmons, Cortney - 2007
Slinker, Dawn - 1995, 1996
Stephenson, Jada - 2023, 2024
Strang, Kristen - 1995, 1996
Taylor, Breanna - 2014
Thompson, Emma - 2024
Traviglia, Caitlyn - 2024
Tyrrell, Sarah - 2023, 2024
Woods, Cierra - 2018, 2019
WHAC PLAYER OF THE WEEK
Barjaktarovich, Jessica - 2014
Capuzzi, Samantha - 2016
Cramton, Faith - 2024
Hopp, Jen - 1994
Kennedy, Kelly - 1997 (x2)
Knight, Jenny - 2000
Loar, Kortney - 2013, 2014
Martin, Angela - 2012
McAlinden, Shannon - 2021, 2023, 2024 (x2)
Playford, Koryn - 2023
Poe, Madison - 2023
Russel, Terra - 2007
Santiago, Robin - 2002 (x2)
Slinker, Dawn - 1995
Taylor, Breanna - 2013
Tobias - 2023
Wilson, Amy - 1997
WHAC PITCHER OF THE WEEK
Block, Audra - 1997
Bollenbacher, Jeni - 2012
Cieczka, Maddie - 2019
Holmes, Kathie - 1995, 1996, 1997 (x3)
Horton, Kim - 2002
Kennedy, Kelly - 2002
Knight, Carrie - 1999 (x3)
Loar, Kortney - 2014 (x2)
Reichel, Lauren - 2021
Shaffer, Aura - 2007
Underwood, Emilee - 2024
WHAC CHAMPIONS OF CHARACTER
Benezra, Amanda - 2017
Bollenbacher, Jeni - 2009, 2012
Dolunt, Kristine - 2008
Drzewiecki, Carley - 2020
Ford, Dana - 2015
Grueter, Maddy - 2023
Jabara, Alyssa - 2018
Jarka, Heather - 2011
Kent, Karley - 2022
Linse, Brittany - 2016
Martin, Angela - 2014
McClelland, Kaleigh - 2024
Nowacki, Ali - 2007
Preuss, Miranda - 2006
Seeley, Courtney - 2010
Shawl, Natalie - 2019
Taylor, Breanna - 2013
Walters, Heidi - 2021
NCCAA
NCCAA NATIONAL PLAYER OF THE YEAR
Underwood, Emilee - 2024
NCCAA FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICAN
Block, Audra - 1995
Holmes, Kathie - 1996
Kennedy, Kelly - 1997, 1998
Knight, Jenny - 2000
McAlinden, Shannon - 2022, 2024
Reichel, Lauren - 2021
Slinker, Dawn - 1995
Underwood, Emilee - 2024
Wilson, Amy - 1997
NCCAA SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICAN
Begley, Abbie - 2021
McAlinden, Shannon - 2021
NCCAA HONORABLE MENTION
Block, Audra - 1996
Finzel, Becki - 1995, 1996
NCCAA REGION PLAYER OF THE YEAR
McAlinden, Shannon - 2022
Underwood, Emilee - 2024
NCCAA ALL-REGION (Midwest)
Anderson, Paige - 2023
Begley, Abbie - 2021, 2022
Grueter, Maddy - 2022
Kane, Cassidy - 2024
Laib, Megan - 2018
Lewis, Payton - 2022, 2023, 2024
McAlinden, Shannon - 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024
Playford, Koryn - 2021
Reichel, Lauren - 2021
Tobias, Katie - 2023, 2024
Underwood, Emilee - 2024
NCCAA TOURNAMENT MVP
Anderson, Paige - 2023
Kennedy, Kelly - 1998
Underwood, Emilee - 2024
NCCAA WORLD SERIES ALL-TOURNAMENT TEAM
Anderson, Paige - 2023, 2024
Begley, Abbie - 2021
Hill, Kali - 2019
Kennedy, Kelly - 1997, 1998
Kennedy, Kristy - 1999
Knight, Carrie - 1999
Reichel, Lauren - 2021
Playford, Koryn - 2023
Starnes, Laura - 1999
Underwood, Emilee - 2024
NCCAA GAMEPLAN 4 LIFE CHARACTER AWARD
Laib, Megan - 2020
NCCAA SCHOLAR-ATHLETE
Anderson, Paige - 2024
Begley, Abbie - 2022
Block, Audra - 1997
Brittain, Elyse - 2024
Bryan, Tyffani - 2020
Campbell, Dee - 2022, 2023
Drzewiecki, Carley - 2019, 2020
Duchene, Hannah - 2023, 2024
Elias, Kate - 2022, 2023
Gehrke, Kara - 2019
Grueter, Maddy - 2024
Hill, Kali - 2019
Hinkle, Megan - 2020, 2021
Jabara, Alyssa - 2019, 2020
Jackson, Mikailah - 2020
Kane, Cassidy - 2022, 2023, 2024
Laib, Megan - 2020
Lee, Bella - 2024
Lewis, Payton - 2024
Malik, Stephanie - 2000
Martin, Megan - 2024
McAlinden, Shannon - 2023, 2024
Paryaski, Emma - 2020
Playford, Koryn - 2022, 2023
Reichel, Lauren - 2021
Rhodea, Lauryn - 2024
Richardson, Melanie - 2019, 2020, 2021
Shawl, Natalie - 2021
Stephenson, Jada - 2023, 2024
Tobias, Katie - 2023
Traviglia, Caitlyn - 2024
Tyrrell, Sarah - 2023, 2024
Woods, Cierra - 2019
NCCAA OFFENSIVE STUDENT-ATHLETE OF THE WEEK
Cramton, Faith - 2024
Lewis, Payton - 2022
McAlinden, Shannon - 2021, 2023 (x2), 2024
Playford, Koryn - 2023
Tobias, Katie - 2023
NCCAA PITCHER STUDENT-ATHLETE OF THE WEEK
Anderson, Paige - 2023, 2024 (2x)
Duchene, Hannah - 2022
Reichel, Lauren - 2020, 2021 (x3)
Underwood, Emilee - 2024
CSC
CSC ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICA (*Award based on performance athletically & academically - CUAA started recognizing in 2016 - previously CoSIDA)
Lewis, Payton - 2023
McAlinden, Shannon - 2023, 2024
CSC ACADEMIC ALL-DISTRICT (*Award based on performance athletically & academically - CUAA started recognizing in 2016 - previously CoSIDA)
Anderson, Paige - 2023, 2024
Campbell, Dee - 2023
Kane, Cassidy - 2024
Lewis, Payton - 2023, 2024
McAlinden, Shannon - 2023, 2024
Playford, Koryn - 2023
Stephenson, Jada - 2024
CUAA started recognizing in 2016 - previously CoSIDA
College Sports Communicators is a 3,200+ member national association for strategic, creative, and digital communicators across intercollegiate athletics in the United States and Canada. The organization was previously known as College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA) and was changed to its new name in August of 2022.
Nominees for the All-District team must have participated in at least 50% of the team's matches throughout the season while maintaining a cumulative GPA of 3.50. The student-athlete must also complete one full calendar year at the institution and reach sophomore athletic eligibility in order to qualify for the honor.
NFCA
NFCA NAIA FIRST TEAM ALL-REGION
Capuzzi, Samantha - 2016
Kane, Cassidy - 2024
NFCA NAIA SECOND TEAM ALL-REGION
Lewis, Payton - 2023
McAlinden, Shannon - 2023, 2024
