The following are the all-time honors for the Concordia University Men's Golf program from the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA), Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference (WHAC), and College Sport Communicators (CSC). The honors are of events played through the 2022-23 season.
| NAIA |
| WHAC |
NAIA
NAIA ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICAN SELECTIONS (3.5 G.P.A. or Above & at least a Junior Academically)
Burk, Andrew - 2022, 2023
Koerkel, Andrew - 2017
WHAC
WHAC ALL-CONFERENCE HONORABLE MENTION
Pagliaro, Joe - 2005
WHAC ALL-CONFERENCE SCHOLAR-ATHLETE (3.25 G.P.A. or Above & at least Junior Academically)
Althouse, Nick - 2020, 2021
Barlow, Kyle - 2009
Bennett, Brayden - 2017
Blosser, Mike - 2017
Burk, Andrew - 2022, 2023
Koerkel, Andrew - 2017
Lane, Nolan - 2017
Louden, Phil – 2005
Lysiak, Travis - 2022, 2023
Miller, Matt - 2018
Reynolds, Thomas - 2015
WHAC CHAMPIONS OF CHARACTER
Bennett, Brayden - 2014
Dorow, Bill - 2007, 2008
Hand, Nathan - 2012
Line, Joshua - 2020, 2021, 2023
Lysiak, Travis - 2022
Marken, Jordan - 2009, 2010
Miller, Devyn - 2017
Miller, Matt - 2018
Pagliaro, Joe - 2005
Pummill, Ron - 2011, 2013
Reynolds, Thomas - 2015
